2009 WinnersJudging CriTeria
In consultation with divisional judges, the national judges will determine the rating of each project against the five weighted national judging criteria. Within each criterion, a number of factors will be considered, including:
Contribution to the national economy
- employment potential
- export potential
- cost savings
- development of infrastructure (ie national asset)
- new industry
- import replacement
- value adding
Impact on quality of life of relevant communities
- natural environment
- urban environment
- health and safety
- resource conservation
- sustainability
Significance as a benchmark of Australian engineering
- media attractiveness
- importance of engineering component
- reputation as a quality project
- recognition as an engineering achievement/innovation
- recognition of standard of excellence
Standing as world best practice
- originality
- overseas interest
- coverage in world literature
- patents and other protection
Extent to which the work has provided a safe and healthy working environment
- For those directly or indirectly involved
- For members of the community in general
The Judges will also consider:
- demonstrable use of sound engineering principles and practices
- originality and/or ingenuity in achieving the best solution
- adherence to budget parameters and program timelines Innovation is an essential element in Engineering Excellence.
The judges will place particular emphasis on the innovation and creativity exhibited in all aspects of the work.
